Twitter Wants to Force Musk to Buy It. But There’s a Hitch

Aug 03, 2022

https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/08/dizajn-bez-nazvaniya-30.png

When Elon Musk chose to back out of his $44 billion offer to buy Twitter, the social media giant filed a lawsuit in the Delaware Court of Chancery.

Twitter has filed a lawsuit seeking "particular performance," an unusual remedy that would oblige Musk to finish the deal.

Unfortunately for Twitter, the guy who offered to acquire the firm is not Elon Musk Inc. but Elon Musk as a natural person. The legal justification stems from the country's ban on slavery in the nineteenth century. This alone can prevent compulsion.

Twitter's claim aims to prevent Musk from additional violations of their contractual relationship, compel Musk to meet his legal commitments, and require the merger to be completed. While particular performance has precedent in Delaware, the Musk-Twitter transaction is unusual. To date, Delaware has only forced one firm to buy another. The Court of Chancery has never forced a natural person to complete a transaction. Although companies are legal people with equal rights for many purposes, other rights are reserved for natural persons alone. One of such rights is the 13th Amendment ban on involuntary servitude, which is a foundation of the rarity of the remedy of a particular performance.

Courts grant particular performance when no alternative remedy, including monetary damages, is available.

Because all land is unique, this solution is most commonly used in real estate transactions. Courts also give a particular performance for one-of-a-kind items such as antiquities and other in-demand items. However, courts seldom accept specific performance for personal services contracts, in part because the state can no longer compel persons to participate under the 13th Amendment.

Beyond the Constitution, there are practical reasons for the rarity of particular performance as a remedy and the courts' disdain for requiring individuals to perform by force. Human nature would cause a person who is forced to perform a service to do a poor job. It is just more feasible and judicially efficient to award monetary damages in order for the party to locate a substitute. In other words, while the court may order Elon Musk to buy Twitter, it would be difficult to order him to run the firm in the best interests of shareholders and other stakeholders. In other words, while the court may order Elon Musk to buy Twitter, it would be difficult to order him to run the firm in the best interests of shareholders and other stakeholders.

Tyson Foods' 2001 acquisition of meatpacker IBP establishes a precedent in Delaware for specific performance as a remedy for a merger. Tyson won a bidding war for IBP but then tried to back out of its $3.2 billion offer. The Delaware Court of Chancery determined that specific performance was the best remedy due to the combination of contract provisions and the difficulties in assessing monetary damages. Tyson broke the contract, according to Leo Strine, a deputy chancellor on the court, and there were no major unfavorable changes to IBP—Tyson just experienced buyer's remorse. "Material adverse effect," Strine stated, is meant to safeguard the acquirer from unexpected circumstances that significantly threaten the target's entire profits potential over time; short-term earnings reductions are insufficient.

Tyson accused IBP of misrepresenting earnings and accounting issues and neglecting to disclose facts to the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Similarly, Musk has accused Twitter of withholding critical information concerning the existence of bots from him by omitting including it in required monthly SEC reports. Strine came to the conclusion that Tyson had not been misled. Developments in valuation reflected market changes and increasing supply-chain expenses. Musk's allegations may meet a similar outcome.

Although Strine believed that specific performance was the best solution, he refrained from compelling it, questioning whether the management teams could collaborate and whether forcing a merger would be best for shareholders and other stakeholders."The impact of a forced merger on constituencies other than IBP and Tyson stockholders and top management weighs heavily on my mind," Strine wrote in his opinion.

Tyson's takeover of IBP was authorized by IBP shareholders on September 28, 2001.

Even in a merger like IBP-Tyson, the judge was concerned about the impact of forcing parties into commitments they no longer wanted. This was true even in the absence of the personal aspect of the Musk-Twitter deal. Musk participates in the discussions as an individual with full constitutional protections and no motive to defend the shareholders and stakeholders involved if he were a business.

There are more questions.

Is Musk's offer to buy Twitter so one-of-a-kind that a substitute transaction isn't possible?

Is the absence of a formal auction and bidding procedure sufficient to differentiate Twitter from IBP? Tyson faced competition, weighed its choices, and placed the highest bid because it felt the firm would add value to its operations. Musk purchased stock privately, conducted the deal in public, and mostly bypassed due diligence. Finally, there is the issue of whether monetary damages are sufficient.

As a result, while Twitter attempts to compel Musk to buy the firm, a court is unlikely to award such a remedy.

The commentary's author bio: Carliss Chatman is an associate professor of law at Washington & Lee University.

Subscribe Our Newsletter

Bank of Russia Proceeds With Digital Ruble, Renews Push for Crypto Ban
Bank of Russia Proceeds With Digital Ruble, Renews Push for Crypto Ban

Meanwhile, according to the TASS news agency, the Ministry of Finance is on track to present a measure governing cryptocurrency by February 18.

Banks and Finance
Traders Believe the Fed Will Ease Policy Soon. Let's Hope They're Mistaken

Milena

Traders Believe the Fed Will Ease Policy Soon. Let’s Hope They’re Mistaken.

A premature change in interest rates may undermine public trust in institutions. Inflation might be the main winner here.

Banks and Finance
Alexander

Are Crypto Wallets Safe? — Tips to Ensure Maximum Protection of Your Digital Assets.
Cryptocurrency and blockchain have been at the forefront of technology for many years, and as the industry continues to grow, investors are drawn to its potential.

discover
Crypto Investing vs. Crypto Trading: What's The Difference?

Tamta

Crypto Investing vs. Crypto Trading: What’s The Difference?

You've probably heard the captivating stories of ordinary folks who struck digital gold and turned into millionaires overnight.

Investing

Contact Us

Contact the Liquidity Provider
for any questions and advertising inquiries b2broker

    Please fill out this contact form to get in touch with us

    / 3000

    By clicking “Get in touch” button, you agree to the privacy policy

    Successful!
    Thank you for your request.
    We will contact you shortly.
    Close

    Alexander

    How Strong is The US Economy Today?

    How Strong is The US Economy Today?

    Alexander

    How Do Crypto Liquidity Pools Work in 2023-2024?

    How Do Crypto Liquidity Pools Work

    Alexander

    What Is The Wheel Strategy in Trading?

    What Is The Wheel Strategy in Trading?

    Alexander

    How to Choose a Forex Liquidity Provider in 2023?

    How to Choose a Forex Liquidity Provider in 2023?

    Alexander

    5 Best AI ETFs for 2023-2024

    5 Best AI ETFs

    Alexander

    What Is an Investment Priorities Plan?

    Investment Priorities Plan - Definition

    Alexander

    What is a Token Maker? – Creating Your Own Crypto Token Without Coding Skills

    What is a Token Maker? – Creating Your Own Crypto Token Without Coding Skills

    Alexander

    How Many Days a Year the Stock Market Is Up? – An Investor’s Guide to Long-Term Success

    How Many Days a Year the Stock Market Is Up?

    Alexander

    Invest $100 and Make $1,000 a Day: Best Strategies to Grow Your Money

    Invest $100 and Make $1,000 a Day: Best Strategies to Grow Your Money

    Alexander

    Is Real Estate Investment Trusts a Good Career Path? — Opportunities in 2023

    Is Real Estate Investment Trusts a Good Career Path?

    Alexander

    Is Day Trading Gambling? Most Likely Yes

    Is Day Trading Gambling? Most Likely Yes

    Alexander

    Where to Exchange Currency Without Paying a High Fee — Planning Your Travel Beforehand

    Where to Exchange Currency Without a High Fee

    Alexander

    Is Infinite Banking a Scam? Unveiling the Truth Behind the Concept

    Is Infinite Banking a Scam? The Truth Behind the Concept

    Alexander

    The Dollar Milkshake Theory: Could the US Dollar Become Even Stronger?

    The Dollar Milkshake Theory: Could the US Dollar Become Even Stronger?

    Alexander

    Why “Skip the Latte” is Poor Financial Advice

    Why "Skip the Latte" And "Cancel Netflix" Is Bad

    Alexander

    Is Now a Good Time to Invest? Exploring Investment Opportunities in 2023

    Exploring Investment Opportunities in 2023.

    Alexander

    Best Bitcoin Wallets in 2023: Comparing Features, Security, and Usability

    Best Bitcoin Wallets in 2023

    Alexander

    Top Rising NFT Artists to Watch Out for in 2023 And Beyond

    Top Rising NFT Artists to Watch Out for in 2023

    Alexander

    Insuring Your Future: What Type of Insurance to Buy?

    Insuring Your Future: What Type of Insurance to Buy

    Alexander

    Is IUL a Good Investment Strategy? — A Guide for Beginner Investors

    Is IUL a Good Investment Strategy? — A Guide for Beginner Investors

    Alexander

    Are Crypto Wallets Safe? — Tips to Ensure Maximum Protection of Your Digital Assets.

    Are Crypto Wallets Safe? — Tips to Ensure Maximum Protection

    Alexander

    Roth IRA Guide: What It Is and What You Need to Know.

    Roth IRA Guide: What It Is and What You Need to Know

    Alexander

    From Gold to Index Funds and Crypto: Where to Invest in 2023 for Long Term?

    From Gold to Index Funds and Crypto: Where to Invest in 2023

    Alexander

    Understanding Algorithmic Trading: A Guide for Beginners

    Understanding Algorithmic Trading: A Guide
    Latest News - Liquidity Provider: Business & FinTech Media
    • News
      • Stock Market Forecast
      • Stocks
      • Banks and Finance
      • Companies
      • Crypto
      • Forex
      • AI
      • Technology
      • DeFi
      • NFT
    • Articles
      • Crypto Payments
      • Trading
      • Crypto Exchange Business
      • Forex Business
      • Fintech
      • Liquidity
      • FinTech Awards
      • Blockchain
      • Investing
      • NFT
      • DeFi
    • More
      • Videos
      • Liquidity Providers List
      • Crypto Payment Providers
    [email protected]

    © 2023 Liquidity Provider. All Rights Reserved

    Privacy Policy Cookie Policy
    This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site.