• News
    • Stocks
    • Banks and Finance
    • Companies
    • Crypto
    • Forex
  • Videos
  • Articles
    • Forex CRM
    • Crypto Payments
    • Trading
    • Crypto Exchange Business
    • Forex Business
    • Fintech
    • Liquidity
    • FinTech Awards
  • Liquidity Providers List
  • Crypto Payment Providers

Dark Theme

China’s Economic Numbers Once Again Have the Skeptics Suspicious

Jan 18, 2022

China’s Economic Numbers Once Again Have the Skeptics Suspicious

China's economic figures are not especially well-known for their trustworthiness or transparency. From broad economic growth to more precise indicators such as employment, many experts — particularly Western economists — have long expressed reservations about Beijing's estimates.

A lead author Frank Zhang wrote that in a 2020 Yale research conducted in partnership with China's elite Fudan University compared GDP data to the final figures supplied by local officials, concluding that "the evidence is extremely apparent that the statistics have been falsified."

As a result, it's unsurprising that many greeted Monday's preliminary release of economic figures for 2021 with suspicion.

China's National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) reported that the GDP increased at an annual rate of 8.1 percent in 2021. That looks incredibly robust on the surface — Goldman Sachs Group's current projection for US growth in 2021 is 3.8 percent. China's figure is based on a very low baseline from 2020 when the country's economy was afflicted by the coronavirus and officially grew at 2.2 percent.

China closed last year with robust exports and factory output, with value-added industrial output up 4.3 percent year on year in December, but with lackluster consumption, with retail sales increasing only 1.7 percent.

Whether the baseline is low or not, 8.1 percent is the strongest performance in a decade for the Chinese economy.

"I've been poring over China's data to determine why the quarterly change in GDP was revised significantly higher in the third quarter and estimated at an extraordinary 1.6 percent — nearly 6.5 percent annualized — in the final quarter," said George Magnus, an associate at the University of Oxford's China Centre.

"It defies belief that this depicts an economy in which the property sector elephant began contracting, consumption fell, and Covid-related shutdowns began" at year's end, he told Barron's on Tuesday.

Indeed, China's real estate industry contracted nearly twice as rapidly as it did the previous quarter, falling 2.9 percent following a 1.6 percent decline in the third quarter. According to official figures, this was also the first consecutive quarterly decline in 13 years.

This is particularly painful for a country like China, where the property industry is expected to account for a stunning 30% of total GDP.

For example, many analysts believe that if the already-difficult real estate market collapses completely, the impact on total GDP would be severe. "A 20% decline in real estate activity," Harvard economist Kenneth Rogoff previously told Barron's, "Could result in a 5-10% decline in GDP." Despite his unyielding skepticism, Magnus presented several explanations for the supposedly conflicting evidence.

"One is the contrast between sluggish spending and a poor sector of the estate on the one hand and more robust production and exports on the other," he explained. "The second is that both areas rebounded after the negative impact of power outages and increased costs in the late summer and early fall subsided in their sector."

Still, it would be astonishing if the economy expanded at a 6.5 percent annualized pace in the fourth quarter of 2021, he added. "I do not believe that this really represents what is happening in China and that the government's rhetoric in this case — supply shocks, demand contraction, and less strong expectations — is for once more true than the statistics imply," he added.

China faced "many tests of a dangerous and complicated worldwide environment and occasional pandemic breakouts at home," the NBS stated in an official statement accompanying the statistics release.

In a tweet Monday, Magnus mentioned five governmental changes that appear dubious in light of China's shockingly good official results.

"Why the frenzy of rate cuts, RRR reductions, and increased infrastructure spending?" he wrote.

Nonetheless, not all external observers viewed the figures suspiciously. Michael Pettis, a finance professor at Peking University and a frequent critic of Beijing's policies and lack of openness, forecast somewhat worse figures for the year — around 7.8%. However, he saw few abnormalities as the year drew to a conclusion.

"There will always be complaints of the NBS data's openness, but I have no reason to believe the Q4 data was wrong," he told Barron's.

"It would have been really beneficial if they had revealed the quarter-on-quarter increase rate, which they often do but did not this time, which may have contributed to people's suspicion," he added.

Subscribe Our Newsletter

14 More Philanthropists Join The Ranks Of Gates’ Giving Pledge
14 More Philanthropists Join The Ranks Of Gates’ Giving Pledge

The Giving Pledge, a worldwide, multigenerational organization revealed on Tuesday that 14 new participants had joined since last December. Founders Bill Gates, Melinda French Gates and Warren Buffett formed the Giving Pledge 11 years ago.

Banks and Finance
Moderna and Netflix Are the S&P 500’s Worst-Performing Stocks This Year
Moderna and Netflix Are the S&P 500’s Worst-Performing Stocks This Year

In January, the equity market took a huge hit, with the S&P 500 dropping about 10% as investors anticipate future Fed's interest rate rises and struggle with increasing bond rates.

Stocks
Oliver

What is the Ethereum Merge, And How Will it Change Ethereum?
The "Merge" of Ethereum, which supporters claim will improve the asset's value in the long term and substantially change the future of cryptocurrency, was a largely anticipated and historic moment in the crypto world.

discover
5 Most Successful FinTech Industry Startups in 2022

Constantine

5 Most Successful FinTech Industry Startups in 2022

The financial services industry is undergoing a paradigm shift as a result of technological advancements, which are actively displacing traditional players and traditional business models. Significant changes are achieved through the integration of new financial solutions, reduction in the cost of certain functions, improvement in efficiency and quality of business, and a positive impact on the sustainability of core business development.

FinTech Awards

Contact Us

Contact the Liquidity Provider
for any questions and advertising inquiries b2broker

    Please fill out this contact form to get in touch with us

    / 3000

    By clicking “Get in touch” button, you agree to the privacy policy

    Alexander

    Full Bitcoin Price History: From 2009 to 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2023/01/cover-11-300x203.png

    Constantine

    Top 5 Most Reliable KYC Technology Providers

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2023/01/cover-10-300x203.png

    Alexander

    The Best Crypto Wallets of 2022: Top 5 Picks

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2023/01/cover-2-300x203.png

    Alexander

    Top 5 Most Reliable Forex Brokers of 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2023/01/cover-1-300x203.png

    Constantine

    5 Top-Tier Breakthrough Trading, Crypto and Fintech Industries Software Solutions in 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2023/01/cover-300x203.png

    Constantine

    5 Most Successful FinTech Industry Startups in 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/12/cover-300x203.png

    Constantine

    Top 7 Liquidity Providers of 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/12/liquidity-provider-3-300x203.png

    Alexander

    Top 5 Crypto Exchanges of 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/12/liquidity-provider-1-300x203.png

    Constantine

    Top 5 Most Distinguished White Label Solutions in 2022

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/12/liquidity-provider-2-300x203.png

    Constantine

    What is Crypto Leverage Trading And How Does It Work?

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/12/oblozhka-5-300x203.png

    Constantine

    Top 5 Most Prospective Tokens in the Metaverse.

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/12/cover-7-300x203.png

    Constantine

    How to Mine Bitcoins? – Beginners Guide

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/11/cover-5-300x203.png

    Oliver

    Blockchain for Business. Pros & Cons

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/11/oblozhka-1-300x203.png

    Constantine

    The Future of Stablecoins and Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs)

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/11/cover-3-300x203.png

    Alexander

    What is Web 3.0 and Why Does it Matter?

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/11/cover-1-300x203.png

    Constantine

    5 Benefits of Accepting Crypto Payments for Your Business

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/11/cover-300x203.png

    Constantine

    Hot Wallet vs Cold Wallet: Which Do I Need More for Crypto?

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/11/oblozhka-5-300x203.png

    Alexander

    What is Hedging and How Does it Work in Trading? — Ultimate Guide

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/oblozhka-4-300x203.png

    Oliver

    Pre-execution vs Post-execution: What’s the Difference?

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/oblozhka-1-300x203.png

    Constantine

    What is Slippage in Trading? – Definition

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/shapka-1-1-300x203.png

    Oliver

    How Forex Brokers Make Money? – A-Book vs. B-Book Model

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/shapka-2-300x203.png

    Oliver

    What is the Ethereum Merge, And How Will it Change Ethereum?

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/shapka-1-300x203.png

    Alexander

    How to Spot Cryptocurrency Scams

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/shapka-300x203.png

    Milena

    Exploring the Metaverse: What Does It Mean for the Future of the Internet?

    https://liquidity-provider.com/app/uploads/2022/10/oblozhka-300x203.png
    • News
      • Stocks
      • Banks and Finance
      • Companies
      • Crypto
      • Forex
    • Articles
      • Forex CRM
      • Crypto Payments
      • Trading
      • Crypto Exchange Business
      • Forex Business
      • Fintech
      • Liquidity
      • FinTech Awards
    • More
      • Videos
      • Liquidity Providers List
      • Crypto Payment Providers
    [email protected]

    © 2023 Liquidity Provider. All Rights Reserved

    Privacy Policy Cookie Policy