Expert Opinion: Economic Integration Was Supposed to Make the World More Peaceful. Why Did It Fail?

May 08, 2022

Expert Opinion: Economic Integration Was Supposed to Make the World More Peaceful. Why Did It Fail?

About the Expert : Christopher Smart is chief global strategist and head of the Barings Investment Institute. When lifetime assumptions fall, it's humbling, but there are lessons to be found within the rubble. At least, that's my aim as I prepare for the next grueling phase of the Ukraine conflict and see the world's 11th-largest economy shrivel in front of my eyes. Most markets may be back to where they were before the war, but the globe is not. It's critical to understand why.

The basic concept of me as a portfolio manager was that investment in Russia produced strong returns while simultaneously bolstering progress on political reform and economic integration. The basic logic ran that increasing the country's involvement in the global economy increased the likelihood of political cooperation and peace. It's a central tenet of much Western diplomacy that merits a second look.

I wasn't so naive as to imagine that the "end of history" would usher in a new period of interstate trade, but the notion that economic participation stimulates ethical conduct made sense. As the benefits of German capital equipment, vacations in Turkey, and constantly growing living standards were apparent to a burgeoning Russian middle class. They would seek to support their country's broader interaction with the outside world. Sure, we'd still snarl at each other about NATO expansion or Middle Eastern wars, but the fundamental congruence of economic interests would keep the relationship on track.

It's a divisive concept in academics. "Realists" argue that the best way to understand international relations is for strong governments to impose their will on the weak. Indeed, this school believes it has been vindicated by the awful events happening in Ukraine. The premise that, in the aftermath of the Soviet collapse, the West overreached and failed to earn Moscow's trust has an obvious simplicity to it.

However, the idea that free-market democracies do not fight each other extends back to thinkers such as Immanuel Kant and Joseph Schumpeter. This was the crux of Western strategy toward post-Soviet Russia. Even though Boris Yeltsin had nothing to say about currency rates, there was a rush to get him admitted to the famous G7 meetings in the 1990s. There were armies of foreign consultants like myself whose governments funded initiatives to assist in the privatization of state assets, the creation of new corporate rules, and the founding of retail mutual funds. One important component of the approach was gaining Russian membership in the World Trade Organization in 2012. Trade numbers show that Russia's reliance on global business rose dramatically after the dissolution of the Soviet Union.

During that period, the issues of contention (Serbia, Syria, Iraq, Snowden, Magnitsky, Navalny, and cyberattacks) swiftly swamped any shaky foundations for cooperation (tentative foreign investment, Afghanistan, and space).

By 2015, when Russia had conquered Crimea, I was part of a team at the National Security Council that began to intentionally undermine the economic connection, applying sanctions, discouraging business investment, and shutting off areas of collaboration. The new stunning round of penalties has dealt the ultimate blow to this strained economic relationship.

If this appears to be a catastrophic failure for one great experiment, it may serve as a catalyst for a rethinking of modern economic diplomacy.

First and foremost, we must examine why we failed. It's possible that the realists are correct in predicting that national security considerations will always take precedence. Or perhaps Russia is just the exception that proves the norm. Although free-market democracies may be more peaceful, the Putin government is neither. Would the world be here today if we had invested more in political and economic transition?

Second, we might have to reconsider how we balance economic participation with political or security considerations. The success of the European Union is based on trade and financial flows. However, we have used a similar "integration" policy with China, only to watch that relationship deteriorate. Despite the fact that India is a free market and a democracy, it remains one of the United States' most challenging allies on important foreign policy matters, including current Russia sanctions.

Third, at least in terms of Russia, we've entered a new period of economic diplomacy, relying on sticks to get outcomes where carrots failed. Extreme sanctions have yet to show effects in Iran, although they did eventually lead to post-apartheid South Africa's democratization and international integration. The punishment meted out will drive the Russian economy into a tailspin, relegating it to the isolation of the 1970s. Some measures may be loosened while negotiations for a cease-fire in Ukraine continue, but the true rationale at this point is to cause enough pain to urge regime change. This might happen rapidly or never.

As historians investigate these and other issues, perhaps the most obvious conclusion is that good economic involvement is required to achieve cooperative conduct from another country, but it is far from adequate. That may not appear to be much, but trying to redefine a major premise in Western strategy may be the best we can do for the time being while we pick up the pieces from our previous assumptions about Russia.

If you want to suggest your news and share your professional comments for commercial offers DM us: [email protected]

Subscribe Our Newsletter

Nomura Creates Digital Asset Company
Nomura Creates Digital Asset Company

As for Nomura, it already has a foothold in the digital asset sector with Komainu, a cryptocurrency storage joint venture with CoinShares, and Ledger, which is expected to begin in June 2020. Komainu concluded a $25 million Series A financing round in March, when assets under control surpassed $3 billion.

Companies
Due to Binance's refusal to cooperate, MCA cannot audit the company
Due to Binance’s Refusal to Cooperate, FCA Cannot Audit the Company

The FCA of the United Kingdom has declared that it is “unsuccessful” in its supervision of Binance because the company refused to respond to queries.

Crypto
Get the ultimate solution: B2BinPay Get the ultimate solution: B2BinPay
Sponsored
Nato

Irrevocable Trusts: What is it, and How Does it Work?
Is an irrevocable trust right for your estate planning? Learn about irrevocable trusts, their benefits, and differences from revocable trusts.

discover
An Introduction to KYC: What it is and Why it Matters

Oliver

An Introduction to KYC: What it is and Why it Matters

Security is one of the main aspects of people's well-being. Security control at airports, for example, is not a huge surprise for us since so many people gather in one place to travel. To get on the plane, we need to provide an ID card.

Fintech
Contact us bg

Contact Us

Contact the Liquidity Provider
for any questions and advertising inquiries

    Please fill out this contact form to get in touch with us

    / 3000

    By clicking “Get in touch” button, you agree to the privacy policy

    Successful!
    Thank you for your request.
    We will contact you shortly.
    Close

    Constantine

    How to Start a Liquidity Provider Business?

    How to Start a Liquidity Provider Business

    Constantine

    How to Start a White Label Brokerage?

    How to start a white label brokerage

    Constantine

    How to Start a Multi-Asset Brokerage?

    How to Start a Multi-Asset Brokerage

    Hazem

    Crypto Ransomware – How They Happen and How to Avoid Them

    Crypto ransomware explained

    Constantine

    Best Web3 Browsers in 2025

    Best Web3 Browsers

    Constantine

    Best DAO Projects in 2025

    Best DAO projects in 2025

    Alexander

    Crypto Nodes That Pay: Your 2025 Guide to Top Passive Income Opportunities in Crypto

    crypto nodes that pay

    Alex

    Pi Network: Scam or Groundbreaking Crypto? The Full Analysis

    Pi Network Explained

    Constantine

    Triple Net Lease: Meaning, Benefits, and Strategies Explained

    Triple Net Lease

    Constantine

    Hanging Man Pattern: How to Identify and Trade It Effectively

    Hanging Man Pattern

    Alex

    5 Infinite Banking Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands

    Infinite Banking Mistakes to Avoid

    Aleksander

    Solana Firedancer: Solving Solana’s Biggest Problems with a New Engine

    Solana Firedancer explained

    Alexander

    What Is an Interest Coverage Ratio? How to Use This Financial Metric to Evaluate Company Health

    Interest Coverage Ratio Explained

    Hazem

    After-Hours Trading: Can You Trade After Financial Markets Close?

    After-Hours Trading Explained

    Alexander

    How to Scale a Crypto Exchange Business and Stay Competitive

    how to scale crypto exchange business

    Constantine

    Crypto CrypticStreet Review: The Future of DeFi and Secure Crypto Trading

    Crypto CrypticStreet Review: The Future of DeFi and Secure Crypto Trading

    Alexander

    Bitcoin Power Law Explained: How It Shapes BTC’s Long-Term Growth

    Bitcoin Power Law Explained: How It Shapes BTC’s Long-Term Growth

    Hazem

    Megaphone Pattern​: What Is It? How to Use It In Trading

    Megaphone Pattern​: How to Read & Trade with It

    Constantine

    Top 5 Liquidity Bridge Providers in DeFi

    Top 5 Liquidity Bridge Providers in DeFi

    Hazem

    Max Funded IUL Explained: Is It a Legitimate Financial Strategy?

    Understanding Max Funded IUL

    Alexander

    Tax Refund Timeline: When Will You Get Your Tax Return?

    how long does it take for tax refund

    Constantine

    Crypto Liquidity — What is it, and How to Measure It?

    What is Crypto Liquidity and How to Measure It?

    Constantine

    AI in Finance: A Game-Changing Trend Shaping the Industry

    AI in Finance

    Hazem

    5 Ways to Make Money with ChatGPT and Build Your Wealth

    Make Money with ChatGPT
    liquidity-provider-logo
    • News
      • Stock Market Forecast
      • Stocks
      • Banks and Finance
      • Companies
      • Crypto
      • Forex
      • AI
      • Technology
      • DeFi
      • NFT
    • Articles
      • Crypto Payments
      • Trading
      • Crypto Exchange Business
      • Forex Business
      • Fintech
      • Liquidity
      • FinTech Awards
      • Blockchain
      • Investing
      • NFT
      • DeFi
    • More
      • Videos
      • Liquidity Providers List
      • Crypto Payment Providers
      • White Label Brokerage Platforms
      • Broker CRM Platforms
    [email protected]

    © 2024 Liquidity Provider. All Rights Reserved

    Privacy Policy Cookie Policy
    This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.